Live cattle exported to Turkey suffer ‘prolonged and painful’ deaths

Published by Sorcha McManigan on

October 19th, 2017

Cattle exported to Turkey under Ireland’s plans to increase live animal exports will suffer “prolonged and painful death” by methods illegal in the EU, a leading animal rights group has said.

The comments from Animal International come in the wake of last week’s meeting in Ankara between the Irish Farmers’ Association (IFA), Bord Bia and the Turkish Meat and Milk Board (ESK).

Following the meeting, IFA National Livestock Chairman Angus Woods said that Ireland could supply up to 100,000 head of live cattle to meet Turkey’s annual import requirement of 500,000 cattle.

So far this year, 19,735 live cattle have been exported to Turkey, up from only 1,694 in 2016 as Ireland looks to increases its exports to non-EU markets.

Bord Bia and IFA officials met with ESK Director General ESK, Mr Ethem Kalin, October 2017 Photo: IFA

Mr Woods said that the delegation discussed “all aspects of animal welfare” with veterinarians in the Department of Agriculture and that it was “clear that this is a very important issue for the Turkish authorities”.

“Turkey wants to develop the trade with Ireland and it is very important that this is fully facilitated in every way,” he added.

Gabriel Paun from Animal International said, however, that Ireland will only facilitate cattle to “suffer a prolonged and painful death in Turkey” from animal welfare methods illegal in Ireland and elsewhere in the EU.

Undercover Investigation

As part of an undercover investigation earlier this year, Mr Paun told The Green News that he filmed an “approved” ship arriving in Turkey which contained Irish cattle “fully covered in thick layer of their own faeces”.

The footage also revealed that the animals were insufficiently covered from the burning sun on their way to a slaughterhouse in a vehicle designed to carry construction materials.

The Animal International investigation uncovered further violations of EU animal rights in Turkey including fully conscious European bulls being subjected to inhuman slaughtering.

This includes the bulls being “hoisted to the ceiling by one rear leg before having their throats hacked with multiple consecutive cuts,” Mr Paun added.

Mr Paun said that he doubts Irish officials have visited slaughterhouses or traveled with Irish cattle on a ship to “determine whether the treatment of animals would accord with the expectations of Irish farmers”.

He believes the truth about the live export industry has failed to be presented to Irish farmers and to Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Michael Creed.

“I am sure that if properly briefed, both the farmers and the Minister would seek solutions to keep Irish animals in Ireland”, Mr Paun said.

In July, the Minister recognised that there is an issue with standards in certain non-EU countries when he launched the National Farmed Animal Health Strategy.

Mr Creed said that department was working closely with the World Organisation for Animal Health in relation to their capacity building activities relating to the welfare of animals at the time of slaughter in third countries.

The Minister has previously said that his Department is focused on developing new links with the Middle East and Asian markets which include countries such as South Korea, China, and Egypt.

[x_author title=”About the Author”]

Related Post
Attempts to ban fur farming set to be renewed in the Dail in September

July 25th, 2018 The Green Party has called on the Minister of Agriculture to support a Bill to ban fur Read more

Educating youth the key to preventing animal cruelty in the future

July 12th, 2018 Since the introduction of the Animal Health and Welfare Act 2013, the Irish Society for Prevention of Read more

Abuse and neglect of our once prized horses on the rise nationwide

June 28th, 2018 Sell the cow, buy the sheep, but never be without the horse. This old proverb once in Read more

Irish State accused of facilitating unlawful transport of calves to Europe
Inside one of the trucks transporting calves to The Netherlands Photo: Eyes of Animals

June 7th, 2018 The Irish authorities stand accused of facilitating the transportation of unweaned calves as young as two weeks Read more


Sorcha McManigan

Sorcha has a Degree Honours in Journalism with French from DIT and is passionate about social issues and radio production