Urgent and radical overhaul of forestry policy needed
September 2nd, 2019
The Irish Wildlife Trust (IWT) has called for a radical overhaul of our forestry sector toward a focus on native species rich continuous cover woodland following the release of the Government’s new planting targets.
The conservation group’s call follows the announcement that 22 million trees will need to be planted every year for the next 20 years in order to hit targets in the Government’s new climate plan.
It is planned that short-rotation conifer plantations will account for 70 per cent of new afforestation, and the remaining 30 per cent of the trees will be broadleaves. Sitka Spruce remains the predominant species used in forestry as it has proven to be one of the most productive conifers for processing.
In 2017, Sitka made up 51 per cent of all trees planted in Ireland – a total of 343,310 hectares. The total area of grant-aided afforestation for Sitka and lodgepole pine increased from 48 per cent in 2004 to 74 per cent in 2018.
The IWT said, however, that this form of forestry is failing on nearly every biodiversity measure and is driving extinction, water pollution, and rural decline. IWT campaign officer Pádraic Fogarty said that the new planting figures do not reflect a change of policy and is “designed merely to grab headlines”.
With just 11 per cent, or 770,000 hectares, Ireland currently has one of the lowest levels of forest cover in Europe, yet also has one of the highest rates of plantation forestry across the bloc.
According to the National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS), our current forestry model is currently a significant threat and pressure on habitats and species protected under European law.
The Environmental Protection Agency has also found that forestry is the greatest pressure on our last remaining lakes and rivers of high ecological value. In addition, plantation forestry supports a lower diversity and abundance of bird species relative to native broadleaves and supports fewer specialist species.
Bird species in Ireland known to be under pressure from afforestation include Hen Harrier, Merlin, Golden Plover, Bewicks Swan, Greenland White-fronted Goose, and Dunlin.
The IWT, Mr Fogarty said, would prefer to see ambitious targets set for woodland cover to approach 30 and 40 per cent. Only around two per cent of the country is covered by what is termed native or semi-natural woodland.
This would be achieved through the restoration of native woodlands through rewilding, combined with a commercial forestry sector based on a “continuous cover close-to-nature” forestry model that would eliminate the use of chemicals and the practice of clear-felling.
“Our forestry policy right now is a mess,” Mr Fogarty said. “There is another way which can provide jobs while at the same time restoring collapsed ecosystems and providing a landscape for people to enjoy.”
A recent detailed analysis by the National Parks and Wildlife Service on the status of EU-listed habitats and species in Ireland shows that our remaining native woodlands are continuing to deteriorate.
The Green Party yesterday called for a model that looks at more diverse forests rather than short-rotation monoculture conifer plantations. The Green Party was responding to comments from Forest Industries Ireland that Sitka plantations will continue to be the “workhorse” of the sector.
The party’s leader, Eamon Ryan TD, said that while conifer plantations can store large amounts of carbon, the clearfell model is “failing us on all other counts”.
“We have to move on from chopping down trees every thirty-five years and seeing forestry as only being suitable on marginal land and mountain areas,” he said.
“As we expand our level of forestation we need to change the whole model so that new plantations increase biodiversity, improve soil and water conditions, and help create vibrant local communities, as well as storing more carbon,” Mr Ryan added.
Sinn Fein recently called for Sitka Spruce to be added to the list of invasive species in Ireland and for grants to be limited to landowners who live within 50km of the lands being planted. Sitka is native to Alaska and is an invasive species in several countries including Norway.
Leitrim forestry study
Yesterday evening, the Department of Agriculture released an independent study that assessed the social and economic impacts of forestry in Co Leitrim.
The study, led by University College Dublin’s Dr Aine Ni Dhubhain and Dr Julie Ballwey in conjunction with the Bureau for Economic Theory and Applications in France, also examined the current regulatory environment in the county.
The Department, which hosts the Forest Service, commissioned the study amid growing concern over the conifer plantation model in the county.
Leitrim is the most forested county in Ireland, with almost 19 per cent (30,000 hectares) of all land under forest cover. Sitka is the dominant species in the county, accounting for 61 per cent of the total forest area. Since the setting up of the Forestry Appeals Committee (FAC) in 2018, 89 appeals have been submitted, a quarter of which relate to Co Leitrim.
According to the local campaign group Save Leitrim, the conifer plantation model is having a “very serious negative impact on people, their lives, mental health, businesses, communities, biodiversity, wildlife, and their rights”.
The UCD-led study found that 30 per cent of the forest owners in the county were not resident in Co Leitrim, half of whom come from neighbouring counties, and 26 per cent of forest owners in the county are investors only.
The study found that the economic value associated with forestry and wood processing in 2017 in Co Leitrim was €26.5 million, with over 300 jobs both in and out of the county associated with activities there.
The total carbon stock in forests in the county is estimated to be over 12.6 million tonnes. Forests are recognised in the report as a pressure on water quality, however, agriculture and peat extraction have more of an impact.
Only 61 per cent of afforestation sites were visited in 2018 in advance of an afforestation licence being issued, the study notes, with 67 per cent subject to field inspection before final grant payment was made by the State.
[x_author title=”About the Author”]