What the experts want from GE2020 – Irish Wildlife Trust

February 4th, 2020

Over the past three weeks, as in all election cycles, we have become accustomed to the knock at the door from canvassers or candidates themselves are they vie for our number one at the ballot box.

We have asked leading climate and biodiversity experts to tell us the key policy asks that they have raised with candidates when they come a-knocking.

Next up is Padraic Fogarty, campaign officer with the Irish Wildlife Trust and author of Whittled Away – Ireland’s Vanishing Nature that charts how the grim failure to manage our natural resources has impoverished our country.


It was recently pointed out to me online that the EU has some of the most progressive laws for environmental protection in the world, so how can it be that our extinction crisis is worsening or that our water quality continues to deteriorate?

The answer is that these laws go largely ignored or unimplemented, something which provokes my nervous tik when I hear any government politician boast about the primacy of ‘law and order’.

Our votes on Saturday are unusually critical as they will determine whether we start on the path towards restoration of nature and reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, or if we get another five years of excuses and prevarication – something we cannot afford.

We need to address the biodiversity crisis but, as nature-based solutions could provide a third of the reductions needed to meet our targets under the Paris Agreement, restoring ecosystems is also climate action.

It also happens to be health care action, community resilience action and rural equality action! So, here is what I see as the top four priorities for the incoming government.

Bumblebee Picture By: manfredrichter/ Pixabay

Generous funding the National Parks and Wildlife Service and National Biodiversity Data Centre

Funding for both sections limps from year to year with no certainty of funding is not an onerous burden on the exchequer. Even were we to quadruple their funding to €100 million a year it would only be a shade more than we give to the greyhound and horse-racing industries so this is not a financial issue. However, the NPWS also needs structural reform to cope with this expansion, and needs to be put on an independent footing just like the Environmental Protection Agency.

Full implementation of existing laws

We enjoy the advantage of having done the hard work of crafting environmental and climate legislation and were we to enthusiastically enforce the laws we would already have Marine Protected Areas covering 10 per cent of the ocean, an end to overfishing and dumping unwanted catches, clean and healthy rivers, with our most threatened habitats and species on the mend.

Photo: Aqua Mechanical

New Common Agricultural Policy

We need a new support system for farming to prioritise results-based farming, organic production and regenerative methods. There also needs to be ‘rewilding’ option where farmers are paid for not farming in certain areas. At sea we need to end bottom trawling and properly manage all activities from super trawlers to sea angling.

New land agency to amalgamate Coillte and Bord na Móna

This agency would give both semi-state bodies a new remit to rewild land where no commercial extraction would occur. Profitable forestry – perhaps only a third of Coillte’s land holding –  could be hived off to a timber production company that is based on natural processes and continuous-cover of trees.

The new agencies need to have community participation (not merely consultation) in setting the vision for their local areas. While we’re at it, the Office of Public Works needs to be upended and the Arterial Drainage Act repealed – with new legislation to restore rivers and ensure flood protection is focussed on towns and homes, not farmland.

The vote counting team sort and count votes at the meeting of the Citizens Assembly Photo: Maxwells

Put together a citizens’ assembly on biodiversity loss

The Dáil voted in May 2019 to establish a citizens’ assembly on biodiversity loss. This would be a critical first step in a massive programme of education which can fill the gap left in the mainstream media. This means integrating ecology and environmental science at an appropriate level across all training programs – from catering to engineering – as well as public information campaigns.

Our dysfunctional relationship with nature is at the heart of our ecological crises and this will only be fixed with an ethical shift which sees us all as part of a living natural system. Along with education, the new government should also put a referendum to the people on including the rights of nature in the constitution.

Leave a Comment